Are Dickey’s Franchisees Unhappy?

The Truth Behind the Headlines

Recent headlines and online commentary have raised questions about the satisfaction of franchisees at Dickey’s Barbecue Pit. But when you move past the noise and look at the facts, a very different picture emerges—one rooted in resilience, system integrity, and the proven success of those who follow the playbook.

The Broader Landscape: Unprecedented Industry Challenges

The restaurant franchise sector has faced historic challenges in recent years. Macroeconomic pressure, geopolitical instability, and reduced consumer spending have created an exceptionally tough operating environment. These obstacles have affected all brands, not just Dickey’s, and have understandably heightened anxiety among business owners.

But while these external factors are real, they don’t tell the whole story. The real determinant of success in this climate is how well a franchisee engages with and executes the proven business model.

Consistency Is Key

For a brand like Dickey’s, consistency isn’t just a goal—it’s a non-negotiable. Customers expect the same great taste and quality across every location, and maintaining that standard is essential to preserving brand integrity and customer trust.

That’s why Dickey’s uses a proprietary supply chain and works with a national distributor. This ensures product safety, efficient logistics, and strict adherence to food safety standards. The result? Lower liability risks and more consistent pricing, often below market rates. Franchisees benefit from collective purchasing power while protecting the brand’s reputation.

What Drives Franchisee Success? Dickey’s franchise experience

Franchisees who thrive are those who are actively involved in the day-to-day operations of their business. They follow the established operational model, respect the partnership, and reinvest in their locations and communities. Compliance with key business practices—like required working hours and cost controls—is fundamental.

The track record speaks for itself: long-term tenures, successful renewals, and profitable resales are the norm among franchisees who stay aligned with the system. Those who follow the playbook are typically satisfied and proud of their results.

What Happens When Franchisees Go Off Script

Challenges arise when franchisees selectively follow the model or reject system standards. These decisions often lead to operational issues, customer dissatisfaction, and ultimately, financial loss.

There are clear examples of locations that flourished under one owner but failed under another who chose to disregard the system. In those cases, the breakdown was not with the brand, the franchise model or the business —but with the franchisee's execution. The model works when it’s followed.

The Future Looks Bright

Despite recent hurdles, Dickey’s is in a strong position. Sales are growing, customer counts are rising, and new franchises are opening. These trends reflect not just market recovery, but a system built to adapt and evolve.
Dickey’s continues to invest in digital tools, operational support, and new revenue streams to help franchisees succeed. The brand’s ability to pivot, especially during the pandemic, showcased the strength of its infrastructure and leadership.

The Bottom Line

The narrative of widespread franchisee unhappiness or failure doesn’t align with the data or the lived experiences of successful owner-operators. Those who stay engaged, respect the model, and commit to the business are seeing real, measurable success.

Dickey’s has 216 current franchisees in over 375 Dickey’s BBQ restaurants within their total restaurant portfolio of more than 800 restaurants, across 8 concepts. Dickey’s has more than 80 years of success and growth in the restaurant business, and 30 years of success in franchising.

Franchising is a partnership—and when both parties do their part, the outcome is a thriving, sustainable business. The truth behind the headlines? The Dickey’s system works—for those who work it.

More than one hundred Dickey’s Franchisees share their personal experiences, success and facts about their franchise experiences with brand in their own words in articles and video testimonials here.

If you're more interested in watching videos, check out our playlist on YouTube.